2025 NHL Mock Draft: Hagens and Martone Battle for Top Spot in Deep Talent Pool
The 2025 NHL Draft class features a rare convergence of elite offensive talent and franchise-caliber defensemen, with American center James Hagens and Canadian winger Porter Martone leading a group that scouts compare favorably to the 2015 and 2023 drafts. As the San Jose Sharks position themselves for a potential third consecutive first-overall selection, the lottery probabilities will determine whether Hagens becomes the cornerstone of their rebuild or if Martone lands in Chicago to form a devastating tandem with Connor Bedard.
The Elite Tier: Top Prospects Grid
James Hagens, C, Boston College (NCAA)
Hagens has separated himself through record-breaking production with the USNTDP and immediate impact as a freshman at Boston College. His elite hockey sense and playmaking ability project him as a true number-one center at the NHL level.
Porter Martone, RW, Brampton Steelheads (OHL)
The physically imposing power winger combines soft hands with a 6-foot-4 frame, dominating OHL competition with a rare blend of skill and nastiness that NHL GMs covet for playoff hockey.
Logan Hensler, D, University of Wisconsin (NCAA)
Hensler represents the modern puck-moving defenseman, possessing top-pairing potential with his combination of skating, gap control, and offensive upside from the blue line.
Anton Frondell, C, Djurgårdens IF (J20 Nationell)
The Swedish center has drawn comparisons to Anže Kopitar for his 200-foot game and responsible defensive play, offering teams a safe high-floor option with offensive upside.
Miroslav Satan, LW, HK Dukla Ingema Michalovce (Slovakia)
Son of the former NHL star, Satan brings explosive speed and goal-scoring instincts, though his defensive game remains a work in progress.
Key Insights: Trends Shaping the Draft
This draft marks a significant shift toward North American talent, with USNTDP and NCAA products occupying seven of the top fifteen spots in current rankings. NHL Central Scouting notes that the defensive crop lacks the generational talent seen in 2024 but offers unprecedented depth, with fifteen defensemen projected in the first round.
Swedish prospects continue to dominate the blue line conversation, with Viktor Klingsell and Anton Frondell leading a contingent that emphasizes skating and puck possession. Teams holding picks in the 8-15 range face difficult decisions between high-risk Russian forwards and established Canadian major junior players with lower ceilings but higher floors.
Full First Round Projection
| Pick | Team | Prospect | Position | League |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | San Jose Sharks | James Hagens | C | NCAA |
| 2 | Chicago Blackhawks | Porter Martone | RW | OHL |
| 3 | Nashville Predators | Logan Hensler | D | NCAA |
| 4 | New York Islanders | Anton Frondell | C | Sweden |
| 5 | Utah Hockey Club | Viktor Klingsell | D | Sweden |
| 6 | Seattle Kraken | Miroslav Satan | LW | Slovakia |
| 7 | Calgary Flames | Caleb Desnoyers | C | QMJHL |
| 8 | Philadelphia Flyers | Maxime Doré | C | QMJHL |
| 9 | Buffalo Sabres | Henry Plante | D | WHL |
| 10 | Montreal Canadiens | Oliver Safar | C | Sweden |
Detailed Prospect Analysis
James Hagens has validated the hype surrounding his exceptional draft season by maintaining a point-per-game pace in Hockey East as a 17-year-old. His ability to slow the game down in the neutral zone while maintaining elite acceleration allows him to exploit defensive systems at will. TSN’s scouting department highlights his puck protection along the boards as NHL-ready, a rare trait for a player his age.
Porter Martone presents a different archetype. Where Hagens relies on processing speed and creativity, Martone overcomes opponents through physical dominance and a release that rivals elite NHL shooters. His skating stride requires mechanical refinement, but the raw tools suggest a potential 40-goal scorer who plays a heavy game.
Logan Hensler separates himself from the defensive pack through transitional play. Unlike many defensive prospects who excel in structured environments, Hensler thrives in chaos, consistently breaking up opposition rushes and immediately converting defense to offense with his outlet passing. Sportsnet’s analysis suggests he could step into an NHL top-four role within two seasons.
Critical Timeline and Milestones
The draft landscape will crystallize following the NHL Draft Lottery on May 6, 2025, though ESPN’s lottery projections currently give San Jose a 25.5% chance of retaining the first selection. The NHL Scouting Combine takes place June 1-7 in Buffalo, where medical evaluations and fitness testing often cause significant movement on team boards.
The 2025 NHL Draft itself returns to Los Angeles at the Sphere, with Round One scheduled for June 27 and Rounds 2-7 on June 28. Teams must submit their final draft lists by June 25, though trade activity typically accelerates following the Stanley Cup Final conclusion in mid-June.
Clarity on Team Direction and Needs
San Jose faces a franchise-defining decision. After selecting Macklin Celebrini first overall in 2024, adding Hagens would give them a one-two punch down the middle that mirrors the successful Pittsburgh and Washington models of the 2000s. However, sourcest suggest new general manager Rob Paterson values Martone’s size and goal-scoring as a better complement to Celebrini’s playmaking.
Chicago’s position at second overall offers flexibility. With Connor Bedard already established as the offensive engine, Martone would provide the power forward presence missing from their top six. Alternatively, selecting Hensler addresses their desperate need for a true number-one defenseman to anchor a porous blue line.
Nashville holds the distinction of potentially selecting the first defenseman for the second consecutive year, following Matthew Schaefer in 2024. David Poile’s successor has emphasized building through the back end, making Hensler a natural fit despite organizational depth at the position.
Scout Analysis and Market Signals
The separation between Hagens and the field has narrowed significantly since January. Where Hagens held a consensus top ranking in October, several NHL teams now grade Martone as the higher ceiling player despite the positional value of centers. Elite Prospects tracking data reveals Martone generates high-danger scoring chances at a higher rate than any draft-eligible player in the OHL since Connor McDavid.
International scouting reports indicate Frondell has surpassed countryman Klingsell on several European-heavy teams, particularly those with defensive systems that demand responsible center play. The drop-off after the top five appears steep, with teams picking sixth through fifteenth expressing uncertainty about whether to prioritize need or best player available.
Inside the War Rooms
“Hagens sees passing lanes that don’t exist yet. He reminds me of Patrice Bergeron at the same age with better acceleration.” — Anonymous Eastern Conference scout
“Martone is the guy you want going into a playoff series against Vegas or Dallas. He drives the net with bad intentions and can shoot from anywhere.” — Western Conference head of amateur scouting
“This isn’t a three-player draft like last year. You’ve got legitimate stars at the top and then a cliff. If you’re picking four through eight, you’re praying someone falls.” — NHL Central Scouting director
Summary Outlook
The 2025 draft offers immediate impact talent at the top and unusual depth through the middle rounds, particularly among Canadian major junior forwards and Swedish defensemen. San Jose’s lottery fortune will determine whether this draft is remembered for Hagens’s cerebral playmaking or Martone’s physical dominance. Teams selecting outside the top five face a high-stakes guessing game between high-upside Europeans and safer North American products, with the Canadian major junior contingent offering particular value in the 10-20 range.
Frequently Asked Questions
When is the 2025 NHL Draft Lottery?
The 2025 NHL Draft Lottery will take place on Tuesday, May 6, 2025, with the results broadcast on ESPN and Sportsnet. The lottery determines the top two selections, with odds weighted by final regular season standings.
Who is favored to be selected first overall?
James Hagens entered the season as the consensus number one, but Porter Martone has closed the gap significantly. Current betting markets and scouting consensus suggest a 60/40 split favoring Hagens, though lottery results and combine performance could shift this balance.
Where will the 2025 NHL Draft be held?
The 2025 NHL Draft returns to the Sphere in Los Angeles, California. Round One occurs Friday, June 27, with Rounds 2-7 completed Saturday, June 28.
How strong is the 2025 draft class compared to recent years?
Scouts generally rank the 2025 class as superior to 2024 but slightly below the generational depths of 2023. The top-end talent rivals any draft from the past decade, though depth beyond the first round appears average by historical standards.
Related stories
Grace Patterson leads fact-checking, source verification and corrections review at Canada Edition.